Neither of them matches the styling is the thing. The dark style's should be dark and the light style's should be a light gray.
I like how they are now. If they are like THIS it woud hurt my eyes. Some color schemes are literally too much for me, so I hope they don't do this and leave it alone.
How they are now don't match the styles. Adjusting them accordingly to match the styles will and won't be any harder on the eyes. If anything, they'll be easier on the eyes.
This is what it looks like: When pulled up in CS6 the "blue" is #37639c and it looks almost black to me. Here is what you are recommending it looks like?
Ah, looks like we had a misunderstanding. I'm referring to the lines under each rating, which are otherwise known as borders. It looks like it's been fixed on the light style, but it still needs fixing on the dark style. Here's a mock-up, using the exact hex code the other borders use on the dark style: #333232.
That makes sense now! I don't read that stuff anyways LOL so that doesn't bother me. Now that I see it, the lighter one looks best. It's not over shadowing the bolder numbers and the icons.
Perhaps, but it doesn't match the style.:) It should look pretty much like the bottom screenshot in my post above.