Support Solved DirecTV DVR Deleting Cops Recordings after Choosing "No, Don't Delete"

It started last night, so it must have been something I changed, and it appears to only be doing it with Cops, so it's something I accidentally changed without realizing specifically with Cops.

When I choose "No, Don't Delete" at the end of a Cops recording, it shows all the regular options for a quick moment (Play, Keep, Delete, etc.) and then it gets deleted and only shows the options for non-recorded shows (Series Options, etc.)