Kingdom Hearts II Was Sora justified? *Spoiler*

well i think he wasnt justified they did aggravate him but it wasnt really fair of him to hate them before they had even done anything to him in re:com larxene was a bit out of order the way she behaved but it just made her awesome.... axel never really did anything to make sora angry neither did marluxia it kind of was namine and the organisations fault
namine replaced his memories
organisation 13 kidnapped her
sora destroys them even though it was namine who started it
i dont hate namine shes awesome

 

I say Yes he was justified to stop the organization and heartless

 

No, he wasn't fully justified, but then again he had to do what he could. The organization may have had a good reason for doing what they were doing, but the end never justified the means. They killed people, took people's hearts, kidnapped Kairi, etc. Organization XIII was never justified either.
To me it actually sounds like Sora is being used by people like Donald, Goofy, Mickey, etc. I mean, he was living a perfectly normal life until they came in, and he was just doing what they told him to. If anything, it's THEIR fault. >.<

 

Actually, it was their fault...

*points to heartless*

By the way, they were made by the leader of the org.

 

Heartless occur naturally...

They just artificially made some...

 

No, heartless did not occur before Xehanort made them. You're thinking of the darkness in someone's heart. The heartless are not the darkness of the heart, they merely feed upon it. They are not natural.

 

"As long as thier is Darkness in someones heart, there will always be Heartless."

Such things imply that Heartless are eteral. Being in existance since the begining of time...

 

Except, y'know, heartless are said by the developer to be non existent ten years prior to KH1.

 

Oh?

Maybe they just wern't called heartless...

Maybe they were called something else...

 

Yes... just like Pokemon!

 

Yes and no. Organization XIII really wanted hearts, but they went about it the wrong way. Sora wanted to stop evil, but he could have at least TRIED to see it their way. ^_^" Poor Demyx. Poor Sora. They were both wrong in some from or another. The End.

 

You can double talk your way out of anything.

I like your style, you remind me of myself!

At first through the arguement, I convinced myself Sora was wrong, and Org XIII was correct, however, after being beaten over the head with a Keyblade by Repliku (the KH-V member) I now see the arguement from your perspective.

However, Demyx wasn't the only victim. Other Organization Members suffered similar fates unjustifiably.

 

Bah. Sure, the Organization had a tragic past, and I may even state that the ends justifies the means, but the thing with that policy is that when one faction takes that stance, they can never complain about someone who opposes them. It's like this here. The Organization started messing with Sora first. Sora reacted appropriately. It doesn't matter whether I'm trying to find a cure for cancer or not, if I go outside and punch a cop in the face, I will spend a night or two in jail.

So even if the organization was justified, Sora was too. And we must answer the topic question "Was Sora justified?"

 

I have to agree with my twin here.
Some people were tricked. Others were forced.
And some, misguided.
v.v
​

 

i think he wuzn't justified, It's all axel's fault. if axel did not kidnap kairi i think no fighting against the organization wud occur...

 

My question in the end, is would the Organization have seen things differently if Sora had been more open to them? Would they have stopped using the Heartless to steal living people's hearts to get their goals? A couple of them, perhaps, but on the majority, I think the answer is no. They had no reason to and were manipulating Sora to get what they wanted. So, in the end, it's not Sora to me who needed to step up. It's the Org members who might not have done so bad that needed to ask him for help to get away from Xemnas. The only ones who seemed wishy washy that would turn in the end were Axel and Demyx, and Demyx is the one who gets the most 'why did he do it' about. However, he also never tried anything of asking for help either or I'm sure that Sora would have done something. In the end, Demyx was just in the wrong place at the wrong time. And Axel basically kamikazi'd himself. The other Org members were going to carry out their plans whether Sora was more understanding or not, and they also would not bother to explain anything.

As much as I can sympathize with the Org's plight, all in all it was a plan that screwed over many people who were innocent so they had to be stopped. Being naive to what was going on as well did not help Sora at all. Maybe if someone had just been more clear, he could have done more but no one had information they were giving him. Instead they were mocking him to keep him killing Heartless and he was forced to do things. Some of what we could see in the game, Sora had no honest clue about. So calling him a murderer and wrong for it, I just don't see it. His perspective and knowledge were just not on par to what we were given in the game.

 

When is that EVER confirmed?

 

They were hinting at it though. Sora just never got it, and thought that they were trying to mess with his head.

 

i thought axel was trying to help sora and kairi

 

Just reminding everyone that when days comes out we'll resolve this once and for all.